Not Happy Yann

I have just finished reading Yann Martel’s new novel Beatrice and Virgil. As The Life of Pi is in my top ten books of all time, I was fearful of disappointment and curious whether he could pull off another quirky and interesting book.

Ok, so it is quirky and interesting and some of the writing is glorious but this short novel is at times unbearable and the topic, well, just made me cross.

The book begins with Henry, a successful author, having his book about the holocaust rejected by his publishers because it is too complicated and the public don’t want another book on the topic. He relocates to France with his wife for a change of scene. The introduction is overly long and a quarter of the way into the book the scene is still being set. Once Henry stumbles upon a play-writing taxidermist, things pick up and the story gets interesting.

I know I am not supposed to say this so I will say it really quickly – I am bored by books about the holocaust. The premise for this book is that there should be another way to write about the Holocaust without simply repeating true stories. This could be an interesting idea for an essay and be relevant to people interested in the topic but it is possible to explore man’s inhumanity to man using many other events in history.

The taxidermist, who is writing a play using two stuffed animals as his main characters, is surrounded by animals from Africa so it should have been possible with barely any change to set the play in Rwanda or Zimbabwe or any other genocidal regime whose stories are rarely given a voice.

Once the publishers had rejected Henry’s book in the beginning, I was relieved that we weren’t going to have a book about the Holocaust, but once you get to the end you realise that the whole exercise is a scam to prove that Henry (or Yann) was right and you can write about the Holocaust in a different way. The story within a play within a story is like looking into a pair of opposing mirrors – curious but baffling. This emphasises the feeling that you have been somehow had, that by using smoke and mirrors Yann martel has tricked you into agreeing with him.
This is a shame because there is so much about the book that is extraordinary and there is some truly original thinking to be found.

Well you were right, we were wrong. Hope you are happy Yann.

Advertisements

About Mikaela

I am an artist and writer living in the Perth Hills
This entry was posted in Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Not Happy Yann

  1. Described as the worst book of the decade by Edward Champion.
    http://www.edrants.com/why-yann-martels-beatrice-and-virgil-is-the-worst-book-of-the-decade/

    I started off lovingh PI, but as soon as it became clear it was some kind of fantasy about a story rather than a story, I lost interest. When he got to that stupid floating island.

  2. And the end where you find that none of it happened?

  3. Moira says:

    Oh no, wish I hadn’t read that last comment…

    • Mikaela says:

      Don’t panic – the end is by no means cut and dried!

      • Moira says:

        So far this book is flippin’ ace! I have got to the part where Pi and Richard Parker are the only ones left in the life boat. The description of the hyena was amazing. I want to copy it out and stick it on the wall. Shame I have to do work and other things as I just dont want to stop reading!

  4. meccano101 says:

    I agree, great book, [except the floating island]. I loved what the ending had to say. [I wont spoil it for you Moira]. The best take on the Holocaust for me is Martin Amis’ Times Arrow, well worth a read. The Book thief was also refreshing in it’s take.
    I think I’m more tired of writers writing about writers. A writer writing a book about a writer who has also written a book who then meets another writer and writes about him. This mobius strip of postmodernism has become a very dull tricksy device that often results in the exact feeling you describe, that you have been conned.
    I’m reading Stephen Hawkins – The universe in a nutshell, at the moment. Very interesting an puts everything into perspective. I think you would like it Kaela.

    • Mikaela says:

      Nicely put. I am going to put tricksy into all my reviews from now on! There are lots of really fantastic books about the holocaust and I have read many of them but I think the issue with this was he set out to write a book about the holocaust almost as an exercise to prove he could. Anyway I am now reading The Line Of Beauty which won the Mann Booker in 2004. According to the back cover it is “the definitive reimagining of the decade of Thatcher and AIDS”. It is beautifully written but even so there is only so much gay sex I can deal with on a daily basis so I am off to find something pleasant to read as an antidote!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s